|
:: 12.12.2004 ::
:: Sunday Morning ::
Bush's References to God Defended by Speechwriter
President Does Not Claim Divinity Is on His Side, Gerson Contends
By Alan Cooperman
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, December 12, 2004; Page A06
KEY WEST, Fla. -- Like many evangelical Christians, President Bush believes that God is at work in his life. But he has avoided claiming that God is behind his presidency or U.S. foreign policy, his chief speechwriter said.
"The important theological principle here, I believe, is to avoid identifying the purposes of an individual or a nation with the purposes of God," Michael Gerson said. "That seems a presumption to me, and we've done our best to avoid the temptation."
Bush's references to God have drawn criticism both at home and abroad, particularly in the context of the war in Iraq. Boston Globe columnist James Carroll, for example, has argued on the basis of Bush's statements that "the war on which America has embarked is essentially religious," a contention often echoed by commentators in the Middle East.
Gerson acknowledged some rhetorical missteps, such as Bush's remark five days after Sept. 11, 2001, that the United States had begun a "crusade" against terrorism. Gerson said it was an unscripted comment that White House officials quickly realized would reverberate badly in the Arab world.
But on the whole, the speechwriter argued, Bush's references to the role of providence in human affairs have been carefully calibrated and fully within the tradition of American civic religion. He said that Bush, like other presidents from George Washington to Bill Clinton, has expressed trust in God without claiming to understand all of God's ways.
Critics of Bush's religious rhetoric, contacted after the conference, remained skeptical.
Gerson's assertion that Bush does not identify "the purposes of an individual or a nation with the purposes of God" is "a beautiful statement," said the Rev. C. Welton Gaddy, a Baptist minister and president of the Interfaith Alliance. "I would scream for joy if I thought that statement was the guiding principle behind the president's rhetoric."
Gaddy noted that three days after Sept. 11, 2001, Bush said the United States has a responsibility "to rid the world of evil," and that the president later told Congress that God is "not neutral" in the war on terrorism.
"I think he has slipped over the line on many occasions," Gaddy said.
Read the entire artcle here.
ALSO
Supports Bush 100 Percent
Dissident Voice, CA
... God said that President Bush should continue his Global War on Terror and the militarization of the world. ... Good thing President Bush has an open line to God. ...
posted by me
:: 10:01:00 AM [+] ::
...
|